When I was a kid and the ice cream truck came around, I really did try to be adventurous and sample new things. But it was always the ice cream sandwiches I went back to. They were just so darn reliably delicious and extremely satisfying! But when you're an adult and following the Weight Watchers program, you don't want to blow all your points on an ice cream sandwich.

WW black forest ice cream sandwiches on cutting board

So I created this Weight Watchers Friendly Black Forest Ice Cream Sandwich. This skinny treat is the ideal summer sweet treat @ only 3 WW points on my plan. This recipe was inspired by my Rocky Road Froyo Bark.

Jump to:

🥘Ingredients
🔪Instructions
📖Variations & Substitutions
👪 Serving Seize
🔢WW Points
🍽Equipment
🌡️Storage
⭐ Reviews
📋Weight Watchers Ice Cream Sandwich Recipe (Black Forest)
🍦More Weight Watchers Frozen Desserts

I had never made my own homemade ice cream sandwiches until I made these... and WOW! Why had I not done this healthy, Weight Watchers version with homemade chocolate frozen yogurt, years ago? They are so easy and completely satisfy both the chocolate and frozen dessert cravings! So, if you want an instant ice cream sandwich, this is your recipe!

Cherries also happen to be my absolute favorite fruit and the long-awaited cherry season is finally here! When it comes to fruit, I pretty much live for cherry season, so I’m celebrating by putting my fave flavor combination of chocolate and cherry together, nestled in between more chocolate ; just as they were meant to be.

🥘Ingredients

Chocolate graham wafer
fresh cherries
semi-sweet chocolate chips
homemade chocolate yogurt

*see recipe card for quantities

Black forest ice cream sandwiches stacked , with cherries

🔪Instructions

Prepare homemade chocolate yogurt as per directions (https://foodmeanderings.com/chocolate-yogurt/).Pit, de-stem, chop cherries and set aside.
Lay chocolate graham wafers across the bottom of a 8X8 pan, using 4 ½ crackers on the bottom (reserving the remaining 4 ½ for the top). * It doesn't matter what size pieces they are broken up in, as long as they cover the pan.
Mix in chocolate chips and cherries together with yogurt.

chocolate graham crackers lining bottom of pan — Step 1

Top chocolate graham crackers with the chocolate yogurt mixture and spread evenly. Bang pan gently on counter a couple of times to even out.
Top with another layer of graham crackers. *Again, it doesn't matter what size pieces, as long as they can be cut into 9 squares.
Freeze for 8 hours or until solid.

chocolate yogurt spread onto graham crackers — Step 4

chocolate yogurt filling topped with graham crackers — Step 4

Once frozen, loosen with butter knife or spatula
Then remove from pan in one piece with knife or spatula (it will come out very easily) and place on cutting board.
Cut into 4 pieces. Then into 9 pieces. You will get a total of 9 sandwiches

loosening edges of ice cream sandwiches with a knife — Step 7

ice cream sandwiches being lifted out of pan — Step 7

I'll be honest, I love frozen yogurt as much, if not more, than ice cream. So, eating frozen yogurt is not even a sacrifice for me. This recipe was born out of my homemade chocolate yogurt recipe . And the great thing about this skinny ice cream bar recipe is how quick and easy it is! You don’t have to freeze the chocolate yogurt first; you simply spread it in the pan to freeze, then cut it into pieces after it's frozen.

The biggest challenge for me is the rationing of my chocolate graham crackers. Since I have not been able to find them in Canada, I stock up when we head down to the US every summer, then ration them for the entire year! Fortunately, if I got really desperate, I could order some through Amazon (see link in recipe). Either way, they are a fantastic way to get your chocolate fix when you're on Weight Watchers.

2 black forest ice cream sandwiches on cutting board with cherries in background

📖Variations & Substitutions

Dairy-free - use cultured coconut yogurt instead!
Cherries - you can use canned cherries (drained) if cherries aren't in season and you can't get fresh
Graham crackers - you can use regular graham crackers if you can't find chocolate

Summertime is for enjoying frozen desserts and just because you're on Weight Watchers, doesn't mean you should be deprived. It's not like you sweet tooth is just going away!My Raspberry Frozen Yogurt Bark is one of the most popular Weight Watchers frozen dessert recipes on this blog!

👪 Serving Seize

This recipe makes 9 Weight Watchers ice cream sandwiches. However, you can half, double or triple the recipe by clicking on the blue serving number and selecting the number of servings you'd like. The ingredient quantities will automatically adjust. You'll just need additional square pans.

🔢WW Points

This low point ice cream sandwich is 3 Weight Watchers points on my plan, but it feels like you're eating a decadent little snack. You can plug the recipe into the recipe builder on your app to see how much they are on your plan

🍽Equipment

You'll need the usual mixing bowls, spoons and an 8x8 pan.

🌡️Storage

Store these homemade ice cream sandwiches in the freezer in an airtight container for up to 6 months.

Summer is short so enjoy those frozen desserts while you can! And cherry season is ever shorter, so I would encourage you to make as many of these Weight Watchers ice cream sandwiches as possible. They will keep well in the freezer, in a sealed container or good quality freezer bag, for up to 6 months! So stock up and enjoy...

So if you're looking for cool and refreshing Weight Watchers desserts this summer or WW Ice Cream Sandwich Recipes, you'll love this!

⭐ Reviews

Did you make this recipe? Please RATE THE RECIPE below and leave a comment!

Please SUBSCRIBE (get my FREE E-cookbook) and be sure to FOLLOW ME on FACEBOOK, TWITTER, INSTAGRAM and PINTEREST!