Prize Pumpkin Pie: Easy Pumpkin Pie Filling

This post contains some affiliate links (See Disclosure Policy)

“What do you want me to do?” I asked, apprehensively.

“Just stir it and turn it down when it’s ready”  he said, his head popping back around the door frame, looking somewhat confused by my reaction. “Okay, so when do I flip this?” I countered. I was really concerned this whole thing was not going to end well.

Standing in the kitchen of my new boyfriend’s apartment, less than a month into the relationship, he had started lunch for us, gone off to do something and asked me to keep an eye on it.

My fear that I’d ruin it was not unfounded. I wasn’t always a good cook. And I had burnt simpler meals (i.e. frozen Mc Cain mini pizzas). Burning lunch was not exactly one of the first impressions I wanted to make.

It’s not that I felt some need to show him I could cook so he’d think I was good marriage material. I was 19 years old and had no interest in conforming to gender stereotypes. But that wasn’t the point; I didn’t want to be so useless in my life that I couldn’t even make tomato soup and grilled cheese without burning them.

Although I loved to bake from a very young age, I really didn’t have a lot of interest in cooking. To me, cooking was something you did because you had to eat, but baking… well, baking was just plain magical. The transformation that occurred between counter top and cooling rack was mysterious and metamorphic. And this pumpkin pie recipe was no exception. In the warm cocoon of the oven, pumpkin, flour and a few other simple ingredients underwent a miraculous transformation that resulted in the creation of this silky, gloriously delicious pie.

The Best Pumpkin Pie Recipe

I have been baking and eating this pumpkin pie since I could eat and bake. And it was one of the first solid foods I fed both my kids. My Mom made it for almost every holiday dessert when we were young and it was something we looked forward to at Easter, Thanksgiving and Christmas. It is still one of my favorite things to bake and eat.

I especially love this recipe because It is truly the best pumpkin pie filling I have ever had and I got it out of my very first cookbook (“A Guide to Good Cooking” – The Five Roses cookbook). First published over 100 years ago, it still houses many of my “go to” recipes, including this one. As you can see, the book has been well-loved over the years.

With Easter just days away, I thought about making something different this year, but I just couldn’t think of anything that would rival my prize pumpkin pie. I have tried to mix it up and made other Easter desserts in the past, but it wasn’t the same. So this year we contentedly eat pumpkin pie again.

Thankfully, I managed to keep the soup and sandwich from burning that fateful lunch date nearly 30 years ago. And perhaps that was what gave me enough confidence in my culinary skills and the inspiration to keep going, because I started to venture into the cooking realm around that time. And my Five Roses cookbook, full of simple, basic recipes, served me well during that period. A little more than 2 months after that lunch, I made my then boyfriend/now husband my very first meal where I cooked more than one thing on the stove at a time; deviled eggs and Kraft dinner with hamburger. Don’t ask. I guess,  since those were the only two non – baking things I knew how to make at the time, cooking them together made sense. Still, I was pretty proud.

Years later, the ‘grilled cheese and tomato soup’ incident is still something my husband and I  laugh about when we’re reminiscing about the good ol’ days, as well as the unfortunate pairing of deviled eggs and Kraft dinner. Fortunately for him, my cooking and meal planning skills have evolved in the decades since those meals. And credit to him for much of that – he was able to teach me a thing or two about cooking and encourage me along the way. Fortunately for me, he’s a great cook. Luckily for both of us, we both turned out to be pretty good marriage material!

If you like this recipe, PIN IT for later!~

TERRI’S AMAZON PICKS:

5 from 4 votes

Print

Prize Pumpkin Pie

Easy to make, silky, smooth and magically delicious,  this pumpkin pie is the perfect holiday dessert!

Course Dessert

Cuisine North American

Keyword pie, pumpkin

Prep Time 5 minutes

Cook Time 50 minutes

Total Time 55 minutes

Servings 8 servings

Calories 110 kcal

Author Slightly Altered from : "Prize Pumpkin Pie" A Guide to Good Cooking, Five Roses Cookbook, Pg 81

Ingredients

• 2 tbsp all purpose flour
• 1/4 tsp salt
• 1/8 tsp ginger
• 1/4 tsp nutmeg
• 1/2 tsp cinnamon
• 1/3 cup brown sugar
• 1/4 cup maple syrup *I used no sugar added maple syrup
• 1 cup scalded milk *See video in notes on "how to scald milk"
• 2 eggs well, beaten
• 1 1/2 cups pumpkin canned or fresh
• 1 10 inch unbaked pie shell

Optional Garnish (adding whipped cream will increase the calories and fat per serving size)

• whipped cream
• cinnamon sprinkles

Instructions

1. Preheat oven to 450 degrees F. Mix all ingredients together, except whipped cream. 

2. Pour into unbaked pie shell and bake for 10 minutes. 

3. Reduce oven temperature to 325 degrees F and bake 30 to 40 minutes or until filling is firm (knife inserted in centre should could out clean).

4. Cool before serving. If desired, serve with whipped cream. 

Recipe Notes

Note: video - How to scald milk

Nutrition Facts

Prize Pumpkin Pie

Amount Per Serving

Calories 110 Calories from Fat 18

% Daily Value*

Total Fat 2g 3%

Cholesterol 43mg 14%

Sodium 105mg 4%

Potassium 164mg 5%

Total Carbohydrates 20g 7%

Sugars 17g

Protein 2g 4%

Vitamin A 39.2%

Vitamin C 2.4%

Calcium 6.5%

Iron 2.9%

* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.